Intermediate · 10 min read

Bid, ask, midpoint and apparently different candles

Explain why a chart and an executable price may differ.

Complete lesson · editorial review pending

Prerequisite: Spread, commission and execution costs

On a small screen, scroll the figure sideways or open it full size.

Bid, ask, midpoint and apparently different candles: An immediate one-unit buy at ask and sell at bid loses 0.20 before commission if quotes do not change.
Hypothetical example; not a live chart or forecast. Open full-size figure ↗

Read the figure

An immediate one-unit buy at ask and sell at bid loses 0.20 before commission if quotes do not change.

Learning objective

Explain why a chart and an executable price may differ.

Bid is the quoted selling side and ask the buying side; ask−bid is the spread. A chart may use bid, ask, midpoint or last-traded data. The plotted line alone is insufficient to reconstruct both sides of an executable quote.

With a spread-based quote, a long normally opens at ask and closes at bid, while a short opens at bid and closes at ask. Stop triggering follows the broker’s contract and order rules. A visible bid candle may not display the ask that affected a short.

Provider, timezone and session cut-off can also change OHLC values. Compare matching timestamps and quote types before calling a discrepancy a platform error. Use execution reports and available tick data when reviewing a disputed fill.

Worked example

At bid 100.00 and ask 100.20, an immediate buy and sell of one unit loses 0.20 before commission if quotes do not change. A midpoint chart at 100.10 hides this round-trip spread.

Common mistakes

Do not test executions using midpoint candles with zero spread by accident.

Practice

Record bid and ask alongside a demo order and reconcile them with the chart type.

Check your understanding: At unchanged quotes, what is the immediate round-trip cost before commission?

Sources & further reading

Saved on this device. Export a backup before clearing browser data or changing device.

My learning path

Sign in to use your private workspace.

Editorial review: 15 October 2026 · AI-assisted technical review; independent specialist review pending.

Translation available · editorial review pending